Dear Reviewers,
Thank you for your valuable contribution to maintaining the quality of the IJDACR journal. As a reviewer, your evaluation plays a crucial role in ensuring the scientific integrity of the manuscripts submitted for publication. You are asked to assess the quality of the manuscript, including its figures and tables, and provide recommendations to uphold the journal’s standards.
Rules for Paper Screening
- Scope of the Journal: Does the paper align with the stated scope of the journal?
- Contribution to Knowledge: Does the paper provide new insights or contribute to the existing body of scientific knowledge?
- Logical Integrity: Is the paper free of logical errors?
- Validity of Conclusions: Do the conclusions drawn from the study follow logically from the evidence presented?
- Methodology: Is the methodology explained in sufficient detail, allowing for reproducibility?
- Citation of Previous Work: Are previous studies properly cited and accurately represented?
- Clarity of Communication: Is the information presented in a clear and understandable manner for readers?
- Figures and Tables: Are all figures and tables necessary and appropriately included?
Evaluation Categories
After reviewing the manuscript, please categorize your evaluation as follows:
- Evaluation A: Accept – The paper is suitable for publication without revisions.
- Evaluation B: Accept after Minor Revision – The paper requires minor revisions before publication.
- Evaluation C: Accept after Major Revision – The paper requires significant revisions before it can be accepted for publication.
- Evaluation D: Reject – The paper does not meet the journal's standards for publication.
Evaluation Report
Please complete the review by submitting your evaluation report using the review form provided. Kindly send your completed review form to the IJDACR editorial office via email:
editor@ijdacr.com.
Download Review Form: IJDACR Review Form
We appreciate your time and effort in helping us maintain the high standards of the IJDACR journal. Your feedback is crucial to the peer review process, and we thank you for your contributions.
